On the difference between the compensating and equivalent. However, it is more natural to work in terms of the cv, since disability policy is concerned with the appropriate level of support for people who are disabled. Budget constraint before price change, but after compensation to reach final utility level. Compensated variation x o y y b a y a b x b x a icp y. In the process of introducing these concepts, i demonstrate how to identify cv and ev. Equivalent variation ev both approaches make use of the expenditure function ep,u. This paper derives necessary and sufficient conditions for the difference between the. Documents similar to compensating variation, equivalent variation, consumer surplus, revealed preference. Compensating variation refers to the amount of additional money an agent would need to reach their initial utility after a change in prices, a change in product quality, or the introduction of new products. Using the expenditure function the compensating variation, cv, is given bycv ep1, u0. Understanding behavioral explanations of the wtpwta. Also, try to estimate the change in consumers surplus measured by the area below the demand function. Intuitively, it is due to the deadweight loss in society caused by the tax.
A compensating variation is an income subsidy that compensates a price increase and an equivalent variation is an income tax which yields an equivalent reduction of wellbeing. In general, the cv will be smaller than the amount of money shed need to buy her original consumption bundle. Equivalent variation ev is a measure of economic welfare changes associated with changes in prices. For compensating measures, the initial situation defines u 1 as the basis for comparison, and we must use a variation measure because we are dealing. The amount of money that must be given to a consumer to return him to his original level of utility if a policy imposes a cost, cv measures wta for suffering the cost if a policy yields a benefit, cv measures wtp to receive the benefit measured under a hicksian demand curve, assuming the consumers utility is fixed at the. This is an alternative to the compensating variation, which is the amount of additional income needed to restore an individuals original level of utility if the price of any good consumed changes. In this article we explore the hicksian concepts of compensating and equivalent variation as well as wtp and wta in explicitly dynamic situations. In this context, the compensating variation cv associated with the price change is defined as the amount of income the consumer should receive to get, at the. The equivalent variation how much can we increasedecrease the consumers income to induce the same welfare loss as a change in market prices. Compensating variation, equivalent variation and change in consumer surplus. This choice obviously depends on the problem at hand.
Calculating equivalent and compensating variations in cge. In contrast, the equivalent variation is neutral regarding the choice of value units. Implications for environmental policy younjun kim,1 catherine l. Compensating variation cv equivalent variation ev change in consumer surplus. Given the indifference map in figure 2, point a depicts the initial consumption bundle. Using the prices after the policy change, compensating variation is the amount of income which changes utility by the same amount as the policy. Government revenue from the tax is not enough to provide the compensating variation. Pdf calculating, with income effects, the compensating variation. Compensating variation cv 2 change in income equivalent to the change in prices. Result compensating variation 141 equivalent variation 70. In this video, i introduce two measures of consumer welfare. A proposed policy will decrease the price of x 1 relative to all other goods.
Compensating variation after introducing a change, how much money would have to be given to or taken away from a consumer compensation to place them at their original level of utility action is undertaken but income provided to or taken away to place the consumer at the previous level of utility. Pdf in our experience, all textbook presentations of the slutsky equation under a discrete price change use a compensation scheme based on the. Compensation takes place after the price and income change, so thatcompensating variation usesthe after change prices. Information and translations of compensating variation in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web.
Using the compensating and equivalent variations to define the slutsky equation under a discrete price change ambrose leung robert sproule bishops university bishops university abstract in our experience, all textbook presentations of the slutsky equation under a discrete price change use a compensation scheme based on the compensating variation. Numerical examples are provided in section 6, wherewe analyze the impacts of achange in the price vector. Nonparametric estimation of a compensating variation. Hilary hoynes deadweight loss uc davis, winter 2012 21 81. Our students have sensed this convention is arbitrary in that they have asked, why. Equivalent and compensating variations world bank documents. Compensating and equivalent variation microeconomics. Hanemann 1991 provides a sufficient condition for these variations to be equal and then proceeds, following randall and stoll 1980, to examine bounds on the. Problems involving compensating variation and the income and substitution effects. Compensating variation and equivalent variation youtube. Nov 08, 2009 in this video, i introduce two measures of consumer welfare. The compensating variation required to raise utility back up to v 50 is e1. Compensating variation cv, or compensating variation, is the adjustment in income that returns the consumer to the original utility after an economic change has occurred. Rather than focus on doing math, here i focus on the graphing and interpretation of income and substitution effects, and compensating and equivalent variation.
Pdf using the compensating and equivalent variations to define. Definition of compensating variation in the definitions. Kling,2 and jinhua zhao3 1college of business administration. Incomesubstitution effects, compensatingequivalent. In our experience, all textbook presentations of the slutsky equation under a discrete price change use a compensation scheme based on the compensating variation.
Equivalent variation in income ev x 2 x1 original budget constraint. Introduction this chapter is interesting and important. Compensating variation measures the difference in attaining the inital utility level at the initial and subsequent prices. In this case the indifference curves are parallel, so the distance between any two indifference curves is the same no matter where it is measured, as depicted in figure 14. Homothetic utility, roys lemma and consumers surplus. I 1u p 2 i0u1p 2 spring 2001 econ 11lecture 8 14 at old prices, equivalent variation. This is an alternative to the compensating variation, which is the amount of additional income needed to restore an individuals original level of utility if the price of. Graphical analysis of compensating variation and equivalent variation. Compensating and equivalent variaton i compensating variation is the change in income that would compensate for the price change i equivalent variation is the change in income that would be equivalent to the price change two necessary conditions for environmental quality changes to be approximately identi ed by price changes in demand functions. Using the compensating and equivalent variations to define. Lecture notes, february 26, 2009 consumer surplus and. An alternative decomposition if you are really alert you may have noticed that the way we decomposed the overall effect of the. The paper points out that consumer surplus is known to be a close approximation of.
Mar 26, 20 rather than focus on doing math, here i focus on the graphing and interpretation of income and substitution effects, and compensating and equivalent variation. Problems with solutions, intermediate microeconomics. Lecture 6 ev, cv, and cs compensating variation equivalent. Willingness to pay, compensating variation, and the cost. Compensating variation is the amount of additional money someone would need to reach her initial utility, not her initial consumption bundle. Cv compensating variation of price change, and ev equivalent variation of price change. Compensating variation calculates the income required to compensate an individual for price changes resulting from a policy change. Request pdf willingness to pay, compensating variation, and the cost of commitment hicksian welfare theory is static in nature, but many decisions are made in a dynamic environment. An amount of money that just compensates a person, group, or whole economy, for the welfare effects of a change in the economy, thus providing a monetary measure of that change in welfare.
Equivalent and compensating variation homework help. Leung, ambrose and robert sproule, 2007 using the compensating and equivalent variations to define the slutsky equation under a discrete price change. It also helps to answer a question you may well have been asking ever since we studied quasilinear preferences right at the beginning of the book. Calculating, with income eects, the compensating variation for a state change edward morey department of economics, university of colorado email protected kathleen rossman department of economics, birmingham southern college email protected february 9, 2007 abstract one can easily obtain exact closedform solutions for the compensating variation and equivalent variation in the presence. The cv thus measures the income change necessary to compensate the consumer for the change in prices. Calculating, with income effects, the compensating. Calculating, with income effects, the compensating variation. How much money a consumer would need before a reduction in prices to be just as well off as after the price decrease. For instance, the government considers which goods to. Compensating variation, equivalent variation, consumer. The equivalent variation of a price rise is positive, and the equivalent variation of a price fall is negative. Compensated variation x o y y b a y a b x b x a icp y i0p y icp yi0p y cvp y ux a,y a example.
Pdf using the compensating and equivalent variations to. Assume negligible income effects and that marginal utility of income is constant. We illustrate with a simple example and propose an even simpler solution to overcome this bias in the compensating variation. For normal goods an equivalent variation is smaller than the compensating variation, because money is more valuable before the price increase. See the web note on compensating variation for an example. May 14, 2020 however, the compensating and equivalent variation are the same in one important casethe case of quasilinear utility. Compensating variation is the additional income required to stay at the same utility level under the new prices, while the reduction in con sumer surplus is what the consumer lost expressed in units of income due to the new prices. In this case the indifference curves are parallel, so the distance between any two indifference curves is the same no matter where it is.
The compensating variation cv is a standard microeconomic tool for measuring the impact of changed conditions on individual welfare and thus for evaluating in monetary terms the projected outcome of policy. Compensating and equivalent variations associated with. John hicks 1939 is attributed with introducing the concept of compensating and equivalent variation. Willingness to pay, compensating variation, and the cost of. How much money a consumer would be willing to give up after a reduction in prices to be just as well off as before the price decrease. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Understanding behavioral explanations of the wtpwta divergence through a neoclassical lens. In economics, compensating variation cv is a measure of utility change introduced by john hicks 1939. In this case the compensating variation is negative the individual needs to give away money to compensate for the fact that he or she is better off than before. On the difference between the compensating and equivalent variations due to a change in an exogenously determined commodity.
Both the graphical and numerical examples illustrate this point. In the process of introducing these concepts, i demonstrate how to. Consumers surplus explain the concept of consumer surplus in words and illustrate by a diagram. This implies validity of partial equilibrium ceteris paribus other things being equal treatment. In this paper we define and discuss the properties of the expenditure function and compensated hicksian demand within the theory of discrete choice with particular reference to the analysis of compensating variation. Original utility level final utility level budget constraint after price change. We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. For example, the change in the economic environment can be an increase in the price of a good, or the provision of a local park. Compensating variation is the change in income that would compensate for the price change. In particular, we derived a closed form expression for the logit. This gets us to compensating variation and equivalent variation measures.
Cs spring 2001 econ 11lecture 8 4 compensating variation in income cv given a price change from p0 to p what is the minimum income needed to get to the original level of utility, u0,at the new prices p. Compensating variation cv and equivalent variation ev cv. Three measures of the change compensating variation in in. Thus equivalent variation is the solution to the equation vp. In the first case the compensating variation will be positive and in the second case the compensating variation will be. The equivalent variation is the change in wealth, at current prices, that would have the same effect on consumer welfare as would the change. John hicks 1939 is attributed with introducing the concept of compensating and equivalent variation the equivalent variation is the change in wealth, at current prices, that would have the same effect on consumer welfare as would the change in prices, with income unchanged. Compensating variation and hicksian choice probabilities in. How much can we increasedecrease the consumers income to induce the same welfare loss as a change in market prices.
Calculate compensating and equivalent variation when the price of x1 increases to 2. Only remaining issue choice of p two natural choices. Equivalent and compensating variation if the utility function is not of the quasilinear type, the usual consumers surplus calculations are not valid measures of the real welfare changes i. However, the compensating and equivalent variation are the same in one important casethe case of quasilinear utility. Pdf one can easily obtain exact closedform solutions for the compensating variation and equivalent variation in the presence of income effects when. The amount of additional income needed to restore an individuals original level of utility following a change in the economic environment. Distribution of compensatingvariations for discrete choice. The compensating variation for a price increase from p 1a to p 1b is the amount of extra money the consumer needs to get back to the same level of utility as before the price change. Calculating equivalent and compensating variations in cge models.
161 712 1450 755 605 358 1074 695 941 1108 1152 135 1001 318 1 1460 1492 797 1296 1575 1028 755 708 669 777 778 1621 455 426 696 31 973 673 137 934 629 929 1463 701 391 1380 741 1304 688 73 313 482 673 591